Capital punishment is a difficult medium in our government to debate because there are so many different views of why it should be kept or not, some are moral, some are more pragmatic. There are a lot of problems with it. First off, it's costing American big bucks. Billions of taxpayer dollars are being spent on it, money that could be used elsewhere, like possibly getting us out of debt. We are billions of dollars in debt and putting people on death row is just increasing that. Richard C. Dieter states, "The death penalty is clearly more expensive than a system handling similar cases with lesser punishment." These costs come from a variety of factors. First there's the cost of everything needed in a regular trial that doesn't concern death as punishment. Added onto that is more pre-trial time, experts, more attorneys, 2 trials instead of one, and a series of appeals. The many factors and lengthy trial period cause the death row process to have an extremely high price accredited with it. Life imprisonment without parol would be a better option because citizens still wouldn't have to worry about that person being out on the streets, and it's much cheaper.
Another problem with the death penalty is that it gets rid of a wrongly accused person's possible chance of proving themselves innocent. The man in the photograph to the right, Carlos Deluna, was convicted of murder and executed. Later evidence showed that he had not committed the crime and was wrongly accused. There are many others like this and most of the similar cases that could be out there are unknown since usually once a person is executed, the search for the criminal ends. Over 1,000 people have been executed since 1979 and there is a high change that many of those cases were flawed and the person was not guilty. That possibility of ending the life of an innocent man or woman makes many including myself believe that capital punishment should be demolished immediately, because quite frankly, a judge and the jury never know for sure what happened or who did what, all they can do is vote on what appears to be the case. Illinois Supreme Court Justice Moses Harrison II comments, “Despite the courts efforts to fashion a death penalty scheme that is just, fair and reliable, the system is not working. Innocent people are being sentenced to death......It is no answer to say that we are doing the best that we can. If this is the best our state can do, we have no business sending people to their deaths.” The fact is that no matter what evidence the court is given, there will be cases where there is a mistake and the evidence is flawed leading an innocent suspect to be wrongly condemned of the crime at hand leading to an unjust execution.
-Michelle R.
http://deathpenalty.procon.org/view.resource.php?resourceID=002000
No comments:
Post a Comment